noname,
i think to be fair to the other mums here, let's not judge their situations. i'm sure everyone wants to be a good employer, but sometimes it's not easy, esp if we have on our hands a very "challenging" maid that gives us alot of discipline, attitude and trust problems.
i myself have seen such situations with my own eyes, ie. maids of close relatives and friends, so i know the situation fully well, and i can truly sympathise with alot of these employers.
but my take is, if the maid is unsatisfactory for any reason, no point trying to discipline her, restricting her or withholding all kinds of priveleges. just change maid (altho i know it's not easy) until you find one that you like, is able to do the work relatively well, has a good attitude and you can trust.
that's why i consider myself truly blessed, because being a 1st time employer i ended up with a very good maid that i can depend on and trust.
however, you give me too much credit. i have to clarify that my maid does not provide excellent service as a result of the respect i show her. in fact, i accorded her the respect only after i could see for myself that she is a good maid, simply because i felt she deserved it for the great work that she does for my family.
and please don't misunderstand my situation. i do not give my maid free reign of everything. in fact, i am still very strict with her, and there are alot of restrictions and limitations that i place upon her. she does not even have a day off, but this is at her request. hence, as compensation, i make sure i help her run ALL her errands, ie. send $$ home, mail packages, etc. sometimes, when she sees an item in the papers that she likes (eg. clothes, etc) she will ask me to help her buy, and i will take the trouble to do it, because i know she's not able to as she has no off days.
which brings me to one point i want to highlight. i think a maid's attitude and work ethics has got nothing to do with how we treat them, ie. it doesn't mean that if we treat them very very nice from the beginning they will in turn return us this kindness by being an excellent maid. i think their good attitudes and work ethics are already inborn in them, ie. either they have it or not. nothing you do can "make" them have this. i can see this in my own maid, ie. her good attitude and good work ethic. it's just that once they have it, and you reciprocate by showing them respect, they in turn will try to do their work to the best of their ability, and they will sometimes go above and beyond their duties.
however, such maids really are a dime a dozen. very very rare.