Cat,
nah I dun think so.
Mine was intensive, and she really picked up alot- blending, word families as well as sightwords. Obviously due to the length of time exposure, it will not be as committed to memory as say, 1 word in 1 mth. Say 1 word in 1 mth, bound to remember, haha.
Of cos I have to refresh often, but even when I don't and test her after a lapse, the "rate of attrition"
is not that high. 10 words in her "treasure box"
of hundreds of words isn't that bad. I set aside the ones she's "forgotten", and interestingly, after flashing once or twice, she can remember the next day(s). Still overall gain compared to slower pace, lesser words over a longer time. Cos at least I can take a break to focus on other stuff.
If I do slow and steady, once I stop... it's stagnation too. Stop longer, bound to have attrition rate too. Might seem like less words forgotten, but if looking at %, shld be abt there?
Ahgal is keen, I wanted to stop phonics abt a mth ago. After all, hit the Dolch sightwords liao, and basic word families. But she likes accumulating more cards in her "treasure box"
. Cheap thrill, hahaha. So I resumed last week, bought coloured cards too, she was so thrilled. This week not touching cos we officially trying to catch up with the more advanced music class
, spent more time to review, kickstart music materials.
When Ahgal first learnt to sightread music notes, she was thrilled! Keen to try new music scores. Likewise with reading words, now that she has basic set of skills, she tries to read words on papers/ anywhere. Although I do think her wanting to amass more words is really quite a cheap thrill motivation (to get more cards, coloured cards, new box).
But that said, Ahgal personality very different from Ahboy. Will need different approach for Ahboy. Actually I'm even thinking, next time dun bother to coach Ahboy- will get me mad and get him angry, far easier to outsource. Send him for class, so easy. Aiyah, some days he's so "challenging", I even wonder if when I go maid-less, why not put him in childcare. Then I feel guilty abt feeling that way abt him lah. But really, he eat food, clean up, change clothes... very "uncooperative" ah.
Ahgal willing candidate to be coached by me, so I try to DIY lor. But yeah, very tiring for me too.