Hi Ladies,
Long time no posting liao.
Just tot of coming in to share my experience with GUG.
My gal enjoys the lesson and still do. Every week is the same in the sense that it is free play for 15 mins, then they will sing the same welcome songs, then art & sometimes science(different kind every week), then zoophonics, then the "secret bag" then finally singing almost the same song every week and finally end with their good bye song or "I love you" from Barney.
However, my gal still enjoys and don't find it boring (I think it is the parents who get bored heee). They introduce a different alphalet every week. Maybe today is A, so they will use apple to do art etc. I feel that at this young age, there is a need to repeat the same thing or else they wouldn't be able to learn anything. It takes sometimes before my gal can actually sit down for lesson and learnt the zoophonics etc.
As for commercialise, I do not deny. But anyway these days, it is difficult to find a school which is not commercialise at all. Even the polytechnics are also very commercialised if you knew what kind of marketing tactics they used to attract students to join their schools. It depends on your luck though to find a good teacher. In GUG, my gal went thru 5 terms with one of the teacher and loves her extremely. She see her, she will smile, went to hug her etc. When she upgrade to "Tots" class, she doesn't really like the new teachers. but she still continue with her lesson (I think 'cos she already used to attending class). Took her about 3 lessons, before she went up to hug the new teachers.
Anyway, I feel in the end, it still depend on whether your kid can accept. Like Evon's case, XT cried for 1 term which is an indication to withdraw from the school.
My gal so far is successful in self-feeding & cup drinking training but totally "failed" in the potty training. She will sit in potty but nothing ever go in there. haaaa.. I got a problem 'cos my gal does not feel uncomfortable AT ALL even when she wet or poo in her training pant. Hai~ Depending on her mood, she will tell me she want to pee or poo. I quickly put her in her potty but she never able to pee or poo in the potty. The moment I pull her pants up, she pee or poo there. (Faint)
Cheers~