Hi all, looooooooooong time no post here as life had been busy >_<
About discipline at this age, I have only one person to recommend : SUPERNANNY!!!
http://www.supernanny.com/
the site has video clips so u can see the demonstrations directly, instead of reading pages and pages of books, which i think is more useful
She is also a major advocate of naughty corner/ naughty step that sort of thing
And, esp for mummies who are at the end of their tether cos apparently nothing works, the key word is CONSISTENCY. If you one day use naughty corner method, and then after a few days because u are so pissed off u start to scream and shout and threaten, it sends the message that they can incite that particular reaction out of you. Same with the tantrums - they are looking for a particular reaction - mainly attention of some sort or a volatile reaction - and if u give it to them once or twice, they will stubbornly hold on to that knowledge. Therefore it is all the more imperative that u change that concept that they have.
My friend's grandaughter who, at 4 years old, still throws major tantrums out in public/private, gets a non-reaction from my friend when she tries it with her. She soon stopped that kind of behaviour with my friend.
I believe in distraction (cos it works so well at this age) but negotiation is really not a good idea at any kind of age - it really demeans one's authority as a parent, and children NEED the authority.
The way that I personally do it is this: if he misbehaves, I straightaway hold his arm, kneel down to face him directly at eye level and make sure he looks straight at me, and I speak in a LOW but ANGRY voice (no high pitched screaming/shouting cos that is the kind of volatile reaction that can encourage them), and tell him No, give the reason why No, and say it is not acceptable. If he does it again, I repeat. If he does it a third time, he gets a slap on his wrist, and he straightaway stops. He doesn't repeat the same thing again for some time
I have to say, so far so good. He doesn't throw rages/tantrums, and is always in a happy disposition, and behaves himself 80% of the time when he is outside/ at the nanny's.
Think we all got to consider things from their POV also. OK, their temperament and innate character plays a part in the way they behave, but I think it's important to have constantly good communication with them, read their body language/actions well, and understand that they they are at the moment starting to learn about social behaviour - not easy if u think about it! For all u know, the start of awful behaviour may very well be because their basic needs/requests have been overlooked eg for my son there was once when he was feeling thirsty and wanted a drink, but i didn't realise that. He got sooooo upset and only calmed down when i finallly gave him water. And then after that for a few times he decided to try overreacting to things, but I wisened up by then so it didn't continue.
And ALWAYS ALWAYS praise them. U have to make sure u don't fall into the trap of scolding them more than u praise them cos it REALLY makes a difference - at least from my personal experience. I praise him for every little good behaviour from sitting still in the high chair/table, to eating all his food/eating without creating a mess, to putting his toys away, to following any little instruction I give him. I think I can safely say that I praise him 7/10 times
I think most of us are too preoccupied with things around the home/work/rest of family so it's way too easy to overlook this little detail, but it's so important.
Just my 2 cents'
hope it helps some of u.
Patience all!