sorry was away to feed anthea lunch and put her to bed.
astro, i agree that immersion is the best way to learn a lang. thats why i nvr learn my jap hahahhaha! but when i mean translation i dun mean translating word for word in the sentence, but just the vocab u intend to teach. hence there isnt any syntex (is this the word) involved. yes, sporean students really CMI, chinese compo use eng grammar, eng compo use chinese grammar.. really CMI.
ash, she uses 2 lang in 1 sentence coz she doesnt know how to say in mandarin for some words. for eg she will say "I eat fan4" coz she doesnt know how to say "I" and "eat" in mandarin. prob is also becoz i speak both lang to her, hence she knows i understand her in eng and too used to using eng with me, thus very hard to make her speak mand to me.
dats why pple say its best when both parents speak a diff lang each to the child.
autum, we dun speak dat way coz we know how to speak "effectively" mah... but u realise a mandarin speaker will speak eng with an accent too?? and vice versa?? sometimes when u hear someone speak u can tell he/she is more of a mand/eng speaker. me worse, my lecturer can tell that i am a teochew speaker from my mandarin!!!!
mejo, haha.. opps!

hm.. YT's case makes me wonder, if mandarin/chinese really a more difficult to learn.. even thou its only spoken mandarin..