mummies, i detest cane and i hate hitting. When I was a child, my dad caned me a lot. I can still remember waking in sweat, cos i dreamt he hit me. I don want this to happen to Kira so i will never cane her. I will punish her by taking away sth she really treasures like her teddy she needs for sleep. Or no TV for the next 2 days. But once she shows improvement, I reward immediately to motivate her. Like crossing the road, she used to run across the carpark from her school without waiting for me, I yelled and scolded so many times, it never worked. Once, I asked her to walk back to school and come back to the spot where I want her to wait for me. I did this with her a few times until she stop at the exact spot where I wanted her to be. Now, she never run across the carpark anymore, she would run to the spot and wait there for me.
It takes longer to have the result than caning, caning and hitting is instant result but maybe damaging in the long run, I don know!
I've also realised that she started yelling at other kids, she got that from me. So imagine, hitting her, she will think that hitting is fine and she'll hit too later. What we want our kids change, we have to first change our ways.
Sorry, for the long preaching!