Buttons,
You are still up at this hour asking about pre-school???!!!
Honestly speaking, our little ones are never "ready" for school. The question here is how long the transition stage going to be, and how will the care-givers at the toddlercare ease the transition, and how will parents react when the transition is tough? There are some who will literally cry for a month or more (plus refuse to get out of bed in the morning plus have a crying fit in the car), and there are some who will whine every now and then when they remember that their parents are not around, and there are those who can just settle in from day one and be fine. I have seen 3 year olds starting school and still crying after a week. Are they ready simply because they are 3 year olds? I think not.
At the end of the day, when you wish to start J on pre-school is just a question of trade off. Is he better off in a toddlercare environment (where care-givers are not allowed to accompany after the first few days), or is he better off with a specific set of care-givers until he is 3 and can vocalise his needs and wants very well? It is a question which only the you and Sam can answer, cos this will differ from child to child, and from various care-giver environments. The lack of stimulation should not be the over-riding factor to put the child in toddlercare, cos afterall there are many programs these days to get around this, such a JG playnest which allows care-giver accompaniment and many many others (LittleGym, GUG, MyGym and what not).
Having said the above, I think there certain things which I can share here for parents who are considering toddlercare:
1. Vaccinations are important, cos they are exposed to a wider pool of viruses and bacteria and other common childhood diseases.
2. Establish a routine. There are parents who opt for 3 day toddlercare. That is a darned bad move. The child has to adjust to toddlercare for a day, gets to stay at home the next day, and goes back to adjust the day after, Those are the ones with the loooongest transition stage cos they just don't know what to expect.
3. Keep the goodbyes short and sweet. Don't linger at the gate and keep waving goodbye. The longer you stay, the longer the child will whine and try to reach for you. And the worst whiners/wailers are the ones whose parents cannot resist the urge to carry them "for a while". When the parents put them down again, they will wail longer and louder cos they expect the same treatment again and again and again. Normally the child will be fine and start playing once the parents are out of sight (out of sight, out of mind).
4. Don't re-appear in front of the child until it is time to take the child home (this appears as well to all care-givers your child is used to, such as to domestic helper, the grand parents or even the aunt). Toddlers at this stage have no concept of time. When they spot their caregivers, they think it's time to go home. And when they can't (plus worse still, the caregivers disappear AGAIN), they will have a crying fit.
At the end of the day, toddlercare does have its benefits in terms of a more structured learning environment, development of social skills and greater independence. But it is not without its downsides and its teething pains (trust me, the transition phase may be even tougher and heartbreaking for parents!), so I think all issues should be considered holistically before making a decision. That said, it is also good to do your legwork and homework in checking out the toddlercare environment before putting your child inside. The last thing we all want is that after a painful transition phase, we have to change toddlercare provider (which means another round of transition for the child to a new environment plus caregivers).
Hope it helps. Last but not least, a huge congratulations to Michelle on your little bundle of joy! Emma is gorgeous!