Hong - I tried that method before, because Im simply too tired to get up and sometimes dozed off back to sleep. But I realised, the longer he cries, the harder it is for him to get back to sleep... and once, he even fell out the bed coz i dozed off while patting him.
I have a feeling E's quite rebellious kind. he will get even worser when ever i use to hard appraoch.
Cry it out method - I remember YB, OC and me had the same difficult situation of pacifying bb to sleep at night at first and we were all trying to use the CIO method but only YB succeeded.
Party why i stop trying out its because, I stayed with my ILs then, and when E cries hysterically, he disturbed my ILs, my FIL hate ppl to disturb his sleep and MIL will be very gan choeng to see what happen and dash into my room. As I was surfing around to find a better method of pacifing BB to sleep, I accidentally came across some criticism of this method.. and I thought its quite true, so end up I did not insist to try this method.
What I did was to make sure I follow a strict sleeping timing for Emerson. Off all the lights, Feed him with milk, give him pacifier, and pat him on the bed (instead of walking him ard the house, coz at one stage, he really easily gets distracted with things ard him). Now he sleeps on his own at night, but I make sure Im beside him.. He toss and turn and fall asleep himself.
Its just the napping prob I face now, he must sleep with sarong in the day time... if i go out shopping he will "lao gai" coz very tired.. so I always make sure he gets at least 1 nap in the morn before I go out.