maisy,
want to share with you my gal's case. since P1, she attended Molin (cos they were cheapest in de area
n also gd review). their worksheets are not as thick n words are larger than Wang Lao Shi's. i only have Wang LS's worksheets to compare cos my nephew n niece attend Wang LS. it din bother me then cos my gal had 93 marks for her Chinese last year.
then she changed timing dis yr n had another teacher. during de orientation talk given by the principal (she's a retired local teacher), i realised my gal's teacher wasn't doing what de principal said she told her teachers to do. i spoke to de principal n she told me she'll monitor dis class thru de cctv she has juz installed. there din seem to b any improvement, even after i spoke to the principal a couple of times. hence, my gal stopped classes in May. her P2 result is still 93 marks, de best amongst de 3 subjects! i think dis is an improvement considering de fact dat P2 should be more difficult than P1. also, i din help her wif Chinese cos i was concentrating on her poorest subject Maths.
i was told by her K2 Chinese teacher then, to let her try P1 b4 jumping into tuition but being KS, i enrolled Molin from start of P1.
tink different kids learn differently. my gal, although she din like her Chinese sch teacher, was able to learn from her classes n hence, din need tuition during P1 n 2. if yr child needs more than de usual class time to learn, then she needs tuition. also, i think de tuition centre plays a part too. if my gal cannot cope in P3, i'll probably go to Wang LS cos their standard seemed to be higher than Molin. in my opinion, Molin is good for children who are not so good in de language to start with.
fyi, my gal takes higher chinese in school.